Hollingdean Trees

Trees for upper Hollingdean Terrace and Quarry Bank Road

Would you like to see trees planted in our area? Some of us have formed a small local group and joined the Plant Your Postcode scheme to make this happen. Trees have been proven to improve our health and well-being, increase property prices, reduce pollution, give wildlife a home and take carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere. And they are beautiful.

As of January 2023 I have given up on this as I've learned that the council is not planting trees in streets which haven't had them before. See below to read the whole saga. If you have any questions or would like to offer your support anyway please email .

How it works

Plant Your Postcode is a charity-supported project working with Brighton and Hove City Council to replace tree stumps and plant new trees across the city. People who are interested in planting trees in their area need to form a group and register for the scheme. We have done that and have so far completed step 4 of their how to guide.

In the next step, the council will do a survey to tell us whether it is possible to plant any trees and where they can go. They look at soil conditions, underground pipes, overhead cables, buildings and pavements. Note that we have limited information about how wide pavements need to be, but they have said it would be very expensive for trees to planted in the road.

If it is possible to plant trees in our streets, then we need to collect residents' signatures of approval and fundraise as it costs about £1000 per tree. Then we have to wait for the trees to be planted, usually in the winter. Once planted, the trees need to be watered and looked after.

Proposed area

We would like to plant trees in suitable places along upper Hollingdean Terrace or Quarry Bank Road. It would be great to plant 20 trees, but we may only be able to plant 5 or 1 or 0. It depends on residents' agreement and the council's survey.

About us

This project was started by a few next door neighbours from Hollingdean Terrace to get trees planted in our streets. We had our first meeting on 31 January 2020. We would love to get as many people involved as possible so please email if you would like to be. And thanks to our kids for helping to create this fantastic poster.

Updates

9 January 2023 - giving up
After the phone call below I emailed Polly and learned that trees were put in planters in the Dip because of underground cables. So after some consideration, I've decided to give up on trees in my street or in the Dip. I am happy to do hard work if I know what is needed, but I'm not a natural campaigner. I emailed Jenni to tell her this and thank her for keeping me updated.

13 December 2022 - phone call with CPRE
I spoke to Jenni, and she told me that the Highways Agency is now very strict about minimum pavement widths. Furthermore, the council's tree department is not allowed to plant trees in streets which have never previously had trees. She wasn't sure whether that rule comes from the council or the Highways Agency. She recommended speaking to my local councillors to see if anything can be changed strategically. She also said Ben at the tree department is able to put trees in the ground in place of planters in Hollingdean Dip (but I think they originally wanted trees in the ground but it was not possible), and that I could try starting there as well. So I will try to find out why planters were put there in the first place and I'll contact my councillors.

17 November 2022 - an update from CPRE
Jenni from CPRE emailed me to ask if I'm still interested in planting trees and encouraging me to liaise with residents. I said I was and I have about 30 interested residents on a mailing list, and could someone survey our street (to see if we can plant in the pavement or if a build-out would be required). She said she would get back to me. She also said: The council allocates annual funds for replacing street trees that have been removed. Sadly, there are no regular funds for planting new trees, although residents have successfully fundraised to cover the costs for planting trees in some areas. The council’s standard donation cost for a tree is £346.96 per tree (covering the cost of the tree and the planting of the tree), however, it does not cover additional costs such as removing stumps, repairing root damage to the street and installing new tree pits. Additionally, width restrictions on pavements mean that on most urban pavements (without grass verges) the likely option for tree planting will be build outs into the road. This is expensive and usually means compromising parking available, which can be unpopular. On average the cost to do this is £3,000 for a single street tree.

8 January 2022 - moved this web page
I moved this web page from www.hollingdeantrees.co.uk to here as the domain is up for renewal and I still haven't heard anything from the council about a survey.

10 November 2021 - chat with Penny
After a few emails back and forth asking about when a survey might happen, Penny from PYP kindly came to visit. She said trees require at least 1 meter squared for planting, and the pavements must be wide enough to accomodate a wheelchair (which can be 820mm wide), so our pavements of 2m are (hopefully) just barely wide enough. Other than pavement width, the main problem is underground pipes, which the surveyor can detect using a special not-completely-reliable tool. Also trees now cost about £1000 each to plant in a street, but the city will be planting some this winter. In summary, she thought it was unlikely planting could happen in our street, but she will push to have our street properly surveyed to figure out if/where trees could go.

4 June 2021 - apology email from PYP
The PYP Postcode project wrote to apologise for the delay, but the council has now hired a surveryor who has our street on his list and "should be able to get back to you in a couple of weeks on this". She also says: The initial problem is that the pavements do look a bit narrow so planting might have to be on build outs into the road with the loss of a parking space, this is quite expensive. Will let you know asap. (from Kia)

6 October 2020 - Zoom call with other PYP participants
The call included the project leaders, other interested people and the new Head of Arboriculture at the council. The main issue relating to our project is that a street survey won't be completed until after a new Tree Planting Officer starts work, which will be at least 3 months. Also any planting has to wait on the completion of the council's tree strategy which is unable to proceed because public consultations have all been cancelled due to Covid. So nothing is going to happen anytime soon. Other interesting information: only 2 streets have done an audit of the area though many streets have expressed interest; it costs £3000 to replace a tree stump and £300 to plant a tree in a park; the Arboriculture deals with lots of complaints about roots lifting up pavements and getting under walls so is careful about where new trees are planted; a build-out (where the pavement is extended into the road to accommodate a tree) will be trialed soon in Springfield Road but is a very expensive option; the department's annual budget for tree planting is very small though they sometimes get other funding; there are non-street trees being planned such as a new woodland in Carden Park.

16 July 2020 - email from PYP project to say it's delayed due to Covid and Dutch Elm Disease
The council took its draft Tree Strategy to a committee to sign off before full consultation at the beginning of this year. The draft Strategy contains new proposals, for example about how wide pavements must be to have street trees. We agreed to pause PYP until the Strategy has been agreed. Our view is that a solution needs to be found to resolve the pavement widths issue, otherwise this will mean a slow erosion of the city’s leafy canopy. However, then coronavirus hit and the Strategy has not gone to full consultation…. Meanwhile…. A new Head of Arboriculture has been appointed by the council and he is called Peter Small. We have met with him virtually and he is really supportive of Plant your Postcode and wants to get lots of new trees planted which is great news. The council has signed off an additional new post – Tree Planting Officer (yay!) specifically to work with local groups who want trees planted, such as the PYP groups. The last time I spoke to Peter he was about to go out and advertise for this post. I sent him a list of all the PYP streets to see which ones could be considered for Planting this winter, assuming we start with the wider streets for now, and then we have been hit by another disaster and this time it is in the form of Dutch Elm Disease. This year is an absolute disaster for Dutch Elm disease in the city and the team are working flat out to identify and take down diseased trees and try and stop the spread of the disease. (from Kia)

28 June 2020 - completed step 4
Paul emailed the PYP project the questionnaire from step 4 of their how to guide. It included results of the door-knocking and flyers - of the 130 addresses in and around upper Hollingdean Terrace and Quarry Bank Road, 38 responded. Of those, 34 people agreed to street trees and 4 disagreed. 22 agreed to having trees in front of their homes, and 9 disagreed. I also made a detailed map of the area. They replied "Paul that is so fantastic thank you!"

4 June 2020 - email from PYP that we should keep going
We too are hoping to get some trees in the ground this winter and having spoken at length to the new head of the Arboriculture Department, we're really encouraged that things will start moving on the planting front soon. An Ad is going out now for two more posts for the department, one of which is for a surveyor so once the post is filled we can ask to schedule a survey for your area. In the mean time you and your neighbourhood group could put together a sketch map of the locality as recommended in the 'How To' pack on the PYP website to get things going. (from Penny)

15 May 2020 - email from PYP project about delays
There is a new Head of the Arboricultural team called Peter Small who started at the end of February and he is really positive about increasing tree cover across the city... the council has approved a new post which is 'Tree Planting Officer' and a 0.5 surveying post so there will be dedicated staff to work on and help deliver projects like PYP. We are really happy about this! Bad news... Peter started just as coronavirus hit. The Tree Strategy, which as you know has been holding things up since last year, has now fallen into a bit of a hole and there is no fixed plan for when it will go out for consultation/be adopted. The problem is that until the tree Strategy is sorted out there is no clarity as to what to do about ‘narrow pavements’ due to Highways issues. (from Kia)

May to June 2020 - dropping off flyers
We dropped off flyers to the remaining addresses in both roads.

March 2020 - knocking on doors
We knocked on a few doors in the top part of Hollingdean Terrace, but had to stop because of the lockdown.

11 February 2020 - poster created
With a little help from my friend Pete: Hollingdean Trees poster and flyer.

6 February 2020 - a few answers from PYP
To answer your points: Can trees be planted without agreement? Yes, if the trees are replacing old stumps. However if you are considering planting trees where there haven’t been any in the past, it’s necessary to get the majority of your neighbours ‘on board’. It applies to both owners and residents. (from Sue)

31 January 2020 - neighbours meeting
Based on the How To pack, we had an initial meeting and decided to make a poster to put up on lampposts and put through people's doors.

20 January 2020 - email from PYP with How To pack
It has taken a while, but we now have agreement from the council about the ‘How to Plant’ pack and I have attached it! I can also send as a word document if that’s helpful... I also wanted to flag up that the council is about to go to consultation on a new Tree Strategy and we have heard that they may be setting ambitious targets for tree planting in the city, such as doubling the tree cover by 2045 as part of the Climate Action Plan. It would be really helpful if you could join us in making a lot of noise about the strategy to ensure that this fantastic commitment is fully supported. We want to highlight that trees provide additional benefits beyond their critical importance in reaching net-zero greenhouse gas emissions: trees create more space for nature, supporting hundreds of species of insects, birds and mammals. Trees are also great for public health, helping to cool the city and providing shade, clean air and making streets more attractive. (from Kia)

24 November 2019 - email from PYP
We have been struggling to get the necessary input from the Council on our How to Plant Your Postcode pack. We had hoped to be meeting them in October to finalise the pack so we could then circulate it to our community groups. (from Alison)

3 October 2019 - email from PYP that How To pack s coming soon
There has been a fantastic response from individuals and community groups across Brighton & Hove in response to the launch of our project. 25 potential locations have registered their interest to date and more join each week. We have continued to work up the “How to Plant Your Postcode” information pack, working closely with Brighton & Hove City Council who are very supportive of the project. Our “How to” pack sets out all of the detail for taking part in the Plant Your Postcode scheme guiding you through the process from taking the first steps in talking to neighbours and assessing interest in tree planting in your area right through to aftercare once your trees have been planted... The “How to” pack will be released shortly ... On other news the Council has prepared a new tree strategy for the City. The Environment, Transport and Sustainability Committee will be deciding at its meeting on 8 October (the public can attend - 4pm at Hove Town Hall) whether to put the strategy out to a public consultation. (from Alison)

1 August 2019 - email from PYP
We do apologise for the delay in sending out the Pack to you (we know that lots of you are keen to get ahead as soon as you can!). In the meantime do continue to keep up to date with current news and activities through the website, plantyourpostcode.org,uk. The future is looking very bright for our City’s trees. Brighton & Hove City Council have announced this summer that a fund of £200,000 has been allocated towards the removal of tree stumps and replanting of new trees throughout the City. We have already shared with the Council team the list of sites where people have been in contact with us about Plant Your Postcode to see if some of these may be suitable sites for this fund. Also, the Council have been developing a new tree strategy for Brighton & Hove which will help to ensure that the existing trees are kept healthy, encourages diversity of species in new planting and a continued focus on the importance of trees within the City. (from Alison)

22 July 2019 - email from PYP about How To pack being developed
We have been putting together a “How to” Pack which provides lots of practical information about how to get planting and the steps in the process. (from Alison)

20 June 2019 - Plant Your Postcode project launched
The Plant Your Postcode project is a joint initiative by CPRE Sussex and Hove Civic Society to halt the decline of existing trees and to breathe new life into the city’s streets by planting new trees in every postcode. CPRE Sussex will be working with Brighton and Hove City Council and the Green Spaces Forum to identify potential sites for tree planting. Local people are also being encouraged to suggest new areas for trees and to become involved in planting trees near their homes. (from the PYP website)